Jump to content
NHL'94 Forums

NHL 94: 2022 Edition by Adam Catalyst


AdamCatalyst

Recommended Posts

19 hours ago, AdamCatalyst said:

Hey,

Posted a Beta for you and anyone else to test. But bottom line, I don’t think the penalty call rate will be much lower. I’m pretty much at the floor as far as being able to lower aggression, while still having enough resolution in the rating range to accurately differentiate players. In any case, make sure you compare it to the original. If it is better in the original, than more can be done. If not, we might be at the floor, at least based on my limited knowledge of what makes it tick.

-a

I'm not sure aggression results in penalties, I could never find a correlation there when comparing Aggression ratings to penalty stats in my old Blitz league.

Edit: I see that you did some CPU games and found a correlation. So maybe when under user control it doesn't do anything (much like the Checking attribute)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, smozoma said:

I'm not sure aggression results in penalties, I could never find a correlation there when comparing Aggression ratings to penalty stats in my old Blitz league.

Edit: I see that you did some CPU games and found a correlation. So maybe when under user control it doesn't do anything (much like the Checking attribute)

Yes, energy depletion & recovery rates are substantially different from the original. If you play with very long shifts, you will very likely find players get sluggish. I found that reducing the speed boost noticeably decreases the whole speed of gameplay, since it is such an easy way to get momentum. The players in my ROM have been set with a higher speed and agility in part to compensate.

IIRC, I ran four sets of 16 simulation games with everything constant except all players adjusted to have…

  1. Aggression Max, Checking Max.
  2. Aggression Max, Checking Zero.
  3. Aggression Zero, Checking Max.
  4. Aggression Zero, Checking Zero.

I then recorded the total penalty minutes per game, the number of penalties, the number of body check, shots, and some other stuff I don't recall. I never held on to my raw data, but what my I remember is…

  • Both higher Aggression & Checking attributes had similar impacts on increasing CPU Body Checks thrown & CPU Penalty Minutes. In both cases, the Checking attribute seemed to have a slightly more pronounced affect than Aggression.
  • The difference between Aggression & Checking Max vs Zero, was substantial, like 3x or 4x more penalty minutes on average.
  • I didn't notice any other meaningful correlations.

I also played a small handful of games with these test teams. I didn't notice any substantial correlation between the penalties called on me and the Aggression attribute. Maybe a slight impact from the Checking attribute, but too small a sample, too casual a methodology, and too fuzzy a memory to be sure of anything there.

Are you saying that the Blitz League stats indicated that Checking attribute doesn't do anything for the Player when throwing a Body Check, or just doesn't do anything to increase the likelihood of a penalty call?

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

FYI to anyone who might have missed this. I am keeping an up-to-date thread to document every manual hack in this ROM, with instructions so that people can lift these mods, or adjust them to their own personal liking:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, AdamCatalyst said:

Are you saying that the Blitz League stats indicated that Checking attribute doesn't do anything for the Player when throwing a Body Check, or just doesn't do anything to increase the likelihood of a penalty call?

 

I didn't find a correlation with penalties. Which is kind of surprising since checking is a good way to get one. But probably the User-controlled skaters threw way more checks than AI controlled skaters, so it wasn't possible to see the AI penalties. Same for aggression, there wasn't an obvious correlation between the aggression attribute and penalties per skater in a human-vs-human league.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, smozoma said:

I didn't find a correlation with penalties. Which is kind of surprising since checking is a good way to get one. But probably the User-controlled skaters threw way more checks than AI controlled skaters, so it wasn't possible to see the AI penalties. Same for aggression, there wasn't an obvious correlation between the aggression attribute and penalties per skater in a human-vs-human league.

Interesting! I am convinced that my data on the CPU-only games was accurate, as even with such a small sample size, the effect was so high with clear polarized clusters in the data. But even if Aggression & Checking ratings affects human controlled player penalty rates (and I'm not asserting that they do!) it seems like it is trivial in comparison to how you actually play with the players. And it also seems to me like there is something else going on, perhaps random, and definitely beyond my understanding.

FYI, what I did for every rating, was…

- Test full teams with a single attribute rated the exact same, and kept adjusting these ratings until I could find a minimum and maximum value that delivered acceptable player performance. For instance, I found that a 15/15 shot power was acceptable as an extremely rare value, and that 9/15 was acceptable as a minimum common value, but that 8/15 shot power was too slow for me. So the dynamic range for Shot Power was limited to 9-15/15. 

- From there I could build a composite best & worst player that defined an acceptable range of talent parity. Teams of them were tested to make sure these extreme scenarios would still deliver players that were fun to play, have clear differentiation, and somewhat realistic disparity. This caused me to re-think my maximums & minimum in some cases. Shot accuracy of 15/15 and 14/15 were just too good, while shot accuracy below 6/15 was just not believable. So that range was set at 6-13.

(@smozoma have I thanked you for that hack? Because I never could have done this without it. I needed the extra resolution it provided big-time!)

- Once I was certain about the upper and lower limits for each attribute, I conformed the results of my internal rating system to an appropriate distribution type. This was done by hand, to try and respect innate characteristics of the data. This was informed by the original distributions, even though most of mine deviate substantially. And then of course play tested. So much testing.

All that being said, in the case of Aggression I found that 0-8 gave me enough differentiation between the most and least penalized players in the league, with the fewest amount of penalties called. With Checking however, I found that I needed a dynamic range from 1-13 to adequately differentiate players, again with a minimum amount of penalties called. And in the case of both of these, I used distributions that approximated the original. Gameplay just seemed off until I did this.

I'm not sure who, if anyone, is interested in this kind of thing. But nonetheless, there it is.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

So, there is going to be a version 6.0, despite my honest intentions to give the project a rest. It's going to be an almost entirely invisible update, it's all about the gameplay. I've completely re-done the goaltending, and I'm very happy with how the goaltenders are playing now. I'm still adjusting the body checking and penalty rates. Been working on game pace. Further stamina depletion & recovery balancing. Play testing. Balancing. More play testing. More balancing. See you back here soon with a Beta to test. If you send me a PM, I will be sure to send you one back as soon as the Beta is ready, which should be any day now. Feedback is so helpful.

If you have any requests for v6.0 please let me know. I can't promise anything, but I've taken into consideration every piece of feedback I've gotten, and been able to make some solid improvements from it. Your feedback matters!

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

It would be nice if the game pace was a bit faster than the original without increasing penalty rate, if that's possible. The original game is pretty slow compared with 95 and up. Maybe not to 95 speed but a slight increase would be nice.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 6/2/2022 at 9:11 PM, George said:

It would be nice if the game pace was a bit faster than the original without increasing penalty rate, if that's possible. The original game is pretty slow compared with 95 and up. Maybe not to 95 speed but a slight increase would be nice.

I've got a few questions for you, but only one to start… what team(s) are you playing with when you get too many penalties? I ask because there is a huge disparity between the most aggressive team in the league (Nashville) and the least (Buffalo), and I'm wondering where your experiences lie in that continuum.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I was always playing as the Leafs. I think it didn't matter what team I was against. Still a lot of penalties but I'll keep testing. I was playing for a while with Canadiens and it was a bit better. What I meant originally was ealistically the # of penalties, but maybe it's the same as the original now that I compare them side by side so whatever.

Crap I was just about to test the 5.5 beta again, but realized I deleted it some days ago..

Edited by George
Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 hours ago, George said:

I was always playing as the Leafs. I think it didn't matter what team I was against. Still a lot of penalties but I'll keep testing. I was playing for a while with Canadiens and it was a bit better. What I meant originally was ealistically the # of penalties, but maybe it's the same as the original now that I compare them side by side so whatever.

Crap I was just about to test the 5.5 beta again, but realized I deleted it some days ago..

Thanks for the info! That is helpful to know. yes, Some teams take substantially more penalties than others, and lay twice as many body checks (I.e. Nashville compared to Buffalo). 
 

i will hit you up with a Beta build soon !

Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 hours ago, Fastlane said:

The game description sounds awesome, besides of one thing: that It's harder to score goals! :Dbut that's just for a noob like me, I think

Hey Fastlane, thanks for the feedback! You can definitely get some helpful tips and tricks on how to score from the forums here. It helped me improve my game big-time! :)

The new incoming version will be even more difficult to score goals. Because it's impossibe to please all the people all the time, I've actually been thinking of releasing a few patches with the ROM, so that people can play my intended gameplay balance, or patch it for a personally more desirable gameplay profile. Would only do a few patches, something like a "Rookie" balance for folks like you, a "Bettman" balance (less hitting and penalties) for folks like @George, and an "Arcade" balance for people who want the fastest most boistrous experience possible. Something like that. 

Would that interest anyone?

Edited by AdamCatalyst
incapable of not noticing my own typos
  • Love 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, AdamCatalyst said:

Hey Fastlane, thanks for the feedback! You can definitely get some helpful tips and tricks on how to score from the forums here. It helped me improve my game big-time! :)

The new incoming version will be even more difficult to score goals. Because it's impossibe to please all the people all the time, I've actually been thinking of releasing a few patches with the ROM, so that people can play my intended gameplay balance, or patch it for a personally more desirable gameplay profile. Would only do a few patches, something like a "Rookie" balance for folks like you, a "Bettman" balance (less hitting and penalties) for folks like @George, and an "Arcade" balance for people who want the fastest most boistrous experience possible. Something like that. 

Would that interest anyone?

I would love an arcade patch

 

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, AdamCatalyst said:

Hey Fastlane, thanks for the feedback! You can definitely get some helpful tips and tricks on how to score from the forums here. It helped me improve my game big-time! :)

The new incoming version will be even more difficult to score goals. Because it's impossibe to please all the people all the time, I've actually been thinking of releasing a few patches with the ROM, so that people can play my intended gameplay balance, or patch it for a personally more desirable gameplay profile. Would only do a few patches, something like a "Rookie" balance for folks like you, a "Bettman" balance (less hitting and penalties) for folks like @George, and an "Arcade" balance for people who want the fastest most boistrous experience possible. Something like that. 

Would that interest anyone?

This would be awesome!! Thanks for the consideration 

  • Love 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Cool! Thanks for the feedback guys. For sure then, let's do a…

  1. Rookie Mode patch with less aggressive defensive and less effective goaltending for those still learning how to play-make and score.
  2. Arcade Mode patch for those who want a less realistic faster paced experience. 

I might still do a Bettman Mode path, depending on how the penalties in v6 sort out. Will ask George for his opinion. Based on the feedback I've heard, that should cover it, but if anyone else has a burning suggestion, don't be shy!

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think those two additional options you are considering, will cover the most common wishes! One rom that I could think of personally, is a rom without opponents. I know this must Sound weird, and I dont know, if It's even possible, but if you want to practice the Timing of one timers, this would be helpful. But I am grateful for a noob rom regardless, because that would be the next step anyway. Trying to bring the stuff you practiced into a game. Thanks for your response! 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I didn't even notice it was harder to score compared to the original when I tested it the other day. I just thought I was bad at the game, but in the original it's so much easier to score. Having said that I can still own the Ai 15+ to 0. lol but it's a great improvement.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

OK, first public Beta of 6.0 is ready!

Any and all feedback is welcome and encouraged, but I should stop to explain what I'm trying to do with this for context.

I am trying to revise & refine the gameplay to be both more realistic, and more characteristic of how NHL hockey is played today.

More realistic…

  • Energy should deplete & recover at a more realistic rate, where more realistic shift lengths are rewarded, while tired players recharge much faster on the bench
  • If you are playing with line changes on, you should have to deal with the real life decision of putting on fresh third liners or keeping yoru best out there even though they are showing signs of fatigue
  • The puck should move faster than the players! Seriously, I know this sounds obvious, but in the original it was possible to outstate a wrist shot in some circumstances, while passes were were often faster than than shots. I've tried to balance the speed of skating, to passing, to shooting, with consideration for how quickly objects move across fixed sections of the ice (like skating time from blue-line to blue-line).
  • More realistic speed burst.
  • Harder to score goals.

More contemporary…

  • Faster and more agile skating.
  • Much faster shooting.
  • Fewer hits & penalties.
  • More parity (less disparity) between the best and the worst of the league.
  • Much better goaltending.

Of course there is much more to it than this, but I think that's a pretty decent overview of what I'm trying to do. Now, because I know not everyone shares my same desire for more of a Simulation style gameplay, I am releasing two patches with this ROM to customize the game. One patch will give you a Rookie mode, where the defence it a little more tame, and the goalies aren't quite as sharp. The other introduces an Arcade mode, where the puck and the players move even faster, and the original exaggerated speed boost is restored.

One more thing. I am not going to provide multiple ROMs for version 6.0, just one ROM, but multiple optional patches. Those are located in the ZIP with the ROM. If you don't know how to install a patch over a ROM, I assure you that it is super easy, and can even be done online. I am just too exhausted to support anyone on doing that, so I hope the community can point people in the right direction. If you are using a Mac, I highly recommend the free software Multipatch https://projects.sappharad.com/multipatch/

You will know you have installed the patch properly, because the opening credits will indicate "Rookie Mode" or "Arcade Mode" or "2022 Edition" accordingly.

I am really looking forward to your feedback. And PLEASE point out any errors if you see them! There's been a myriad of minor fixes and improvements, but I won't detail them now.

cheers,

-Adam

 

 

 

@Fastlane The rookie mode is essentially for you, so please let me know how it does and does not work for you, so I can tweak it!

@George Please let me know how you think we are doing on the penalty front!

    @Tabs3121 The Arcade patch is here, let me know if this is what you had in mind!

     

     

    Edited by AdamCatalyst
    Outdated Beta removed.
    • Love 1
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    to apply the patch, if you have windows. this tool is doing it.  Had no problems with it.  A utility called 'Beat'.

    https://www.romhacking.net/utilities/893/

     

    Played a game on each version: each game was Colorado-Detroit.  

    On the 'arcade' version, I wasn't totally thrown off by the speed.  I would make it speedier.

    The 'original' had a great feel.  Had a great game and I scored 2 goals.  Love the flow of the game.

    For the 'rookie' bizarrely, I only scored a goal and thought it would be a goalfest.  The flow of the game is good but like the 'arcade' I would like more goals.  

    I haven't played nhl 94 in awhile so maybe I am slightly offbase with my observations but all I know is that all 3 versions were very pleasant and thus, gives a great hockey experience.  Maybe some twinking is needed to differentiate more the versions from each other.  Other than that, all 3 are great to introduce a noob to nhl 94.

    hope it helps,

    Cheers!

     

    • Thanks 1
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    39 minutes ago, I got the puck said:

    to apply the patch, if you have windows. this tool is doing it.  Had no problems with it.  A utility called 'Beat'.

    https://www.romhacking.net/utilities/893/

     

    Played a game on each version: each game was Colorado-Detroit.  

    On the 'arcade' version, I wasn't totally thrown off by the speed.  I would make it speedier.

    The 'original' had a great feel.  Had a great game and I scored 2 goals.  Love the flow of the game.

    For the 'rookie' bizarrely, I only scored a goal and thought it would be a goalfest.  The flow of the game is good but like the 'arcade' I would like more goals.  

    I haven't played nhl 94 in awhile so maybe I am slightly offbase with my observations but all I know is that all 3 versions were very pleasant and thus, gives a great hockey experience.  Maybe some twinking is needed to differentiate more the versions from each other.  Other than that, all 3 are great to introduce a noob to nhl 94.

    hope it helps,

    Cheers!

     

    Thanks man, I appreciate all the feedback!

     

    • Thanks 1
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    6 hours ago, AdamCatalyst said:

    OK, first public Beta of 6.0 is ready!

    Any and all feedback is welcome and encouraged, but I should stop to explain what I'm trying to do with this for context.

    I am trying to revise & refine the gameplay to be both more realistic, and more characteristic of how NHL hockey is played today.

    More realistic…

    • Energy should deplete & recover at a more realistic rate, where more realistic shift lengths are rewarded, while tired players recharge much faster on the bench
    • If you are playing with line changes on, you should have to deal with the real life decision of putting on fresh third liners or keeping yoru best out there even though they are showing signs of fatigue
    • The puck should move faster than the players! Seriously, I know this sounds obvious, but in the original it was possible to outstate a wrist shot in some circumstances, while passes were were often faster than than shots. I've tried to balance the speed of skating, to passing, to shooting, with consideration for how quickly objects move across fixed sections of the ice (like skating time from blue-line to blue-line).
    • More realistic speed burst.
    • Harder to score goals.

    More contemporary…

    • Faster and more agile skating.
    • Much faster shooting.
    • Fewer hits & penalties.
    • More parity (less disparity) between the best and the worst of the league.
    • Much better goaltending.

    Of course there is much more to it than this, but I think that's a pretty decent overview of what I'm trying to do. Now, because I know not everyone shares my same desire for more of a Simulation style gameplay, I am releasing two patches with this ROM to customize the game. One patch will give you a Rookie mode, where the defence it a little more tame, and the goalies aren't quite as sharp. The other introduces an Arcade mode, where the puck and the players move even faster, and the original exaggerated speed boost is restored.

    One more thing. I am not going to provide multiple ROMs for version 6.0, just one ROM, but multiple optional patches. Those are located in the ZIP with the ROM. If you don't know how to install a patch over a ROM, I assure you that it is super easy, and can even be done online. I am just too exhausted to support anyone on doing that, so I hope the community can point people in the right direction. If you are using a Mac, I highly recommend the free software Multipatch https://projects.sappharad.com/multipatch/

    You will know you have installed the patch properly, because the opening credits will indicate "Rookie Mode" or "Arcade Mode" or "2022 Edition" accordingly.

    I am really looking forward to your feedback. And PLEASE point out any errors if you see them! There's been a myriad of minor fixes and improvements, but I won't detail them now.

    cheers,

    -Adam

     

    NHL 94 [h] 2022 AC v6b1 - 2022 06 07.zip 756.99 kB · 3 downloads

     

    @Fastlane The rookie mode is essentially for you, so please let me know how it does and does not work for you, so I can tweak it!

    @George Please let me know how you think we are doing on the penalty front!

      @Tabs3121 The Arcade patch is here, let me know if this is what you had in mind!

       

       

      Wow! Thanks for this fast update! I will try it out this evening and let you know, how it does! Thanks a ton! 

      Link to comment
      Share on other sites

      So, I was able to test the roms tonight! 

      Rookie Mode:

      At first I scored two quick goals and thought it would continue. But it turned out different. 

      2:2 OT DRAW

      Arcade Mode:

      Wow, this could be my rom! I was able to score four goals, which is the most since my quiet and humble comeback after all those years. I will attach a small video of a weird scene, when the goalie left the house. Good for me, it made me score :) It felt like the movement was faster, but the puck handling was a bit slower if that makes sense.

      4:1 End of Regulation

      Regular Mode

      It was obviously slower, but one timers worked pretty well for me. But this rom naturally feels more competitive from beginning to end. It was a close win for me.

      2:1 End of Regulation

       

      But because this was the first time, I was playing your roms, let me say this: Wow, I can see how much tweeking you did on the visual side! It looks awesome! So many things to discover and it all starts with a great cover and splashscreen! Thank you for all the work you put in! 

      • Love 1
      Link to comment
      Share on other sites

      @Fastlane AWESOME, thank-you so much for all the feedback!

      lol - thanks for the clip. Was it something you said? ;) I've never had the goalie disappear on me before, but I have heard that error exists. Check out this crazy list: https://nhl94.com/html/bugs.php

      I've been so lucky t have you and a few others send me feedback in the last 24 hours, enough that I can put up another Beta tonight. Have made Rookie easier. Arcade faster. And the main version, slightly fewer penalties. If you have time to download test, and provide feedback again, that would be great! If you don't have time, no worries. I'm just happy to hear that you are having fun. 

      Link to comment
      Share on other sites

      Thank-you to everyone who has downloaded and provided feedback in the last 24 hours! Based on all your feedback, here is a second Beta of 6.0! Key changes from the first Beta…

      • Game has fewer penalties, and a few very minor tweaks.
      • Arcade patch has faster skating.
      • Rookie patch has the most changes, hopefully making it easier to score goals, and to learn the goalies weaknesses.

      If you are reading this, and confused as to what the heck I am talking about with the “patches”, check out the linked post above.

      As always, any and all feedback is welcome and encouraged. At this point, there is only one extremely minor tweak I can think to make. Unless you folks can find any errors or issues, it looks like the final version could be published on Friday.

      cheers,

      -a

       

      Edited by AdamCatalyst
      Outdated Beta removed.
      Link to comment
      Share on other sites

      Just tried the regular version and I think you got it. The penalties are much better now I think. It feels like the AI is improved vs 5.4, maybe it's just me. All in all it feels pretty good. Nice.

      Trying to patch the arcade and rookie modes don't work. checksum mismatch.

      screenshot.png

      Edited by George
      Link to comment
      Share on other sites

      5 hours ago, George said:

      Just tried the regular version and I think you got it. The penalties are much better now I think. It feels like the AI is improved vs 5.4, maybe it's just me. All in all it feels pretty good. Nice.

      Trying to patch the arcade and rookie modes don't work. checksum mismatch.

      screenshot.png

      Thanks for all the feedback @George! I'm feeling really good about the base version, just one last issue that probably no-one else will ever notice, but I know is there. :)

      As for the patches, my apologies, I should have been clearer. They can *only* be applied to the corresponding ROM, i.e v6b2 patches will only work with v6b2 ROM. If applied to any other ROM, it will probably break it, which is why I used BPS to implement a checksum safeguard.

      I will make that much clearer in the final release!

       

      Link to comment
      Share on other sites

      Thank you for this quick update! Here are my observations:

      Rookie Mode:

      AI is notably less aggressive! It appears easier to score than in other versions! Thumbs up! But I had another occassion, when the goalie disappeared at the end of the match (didnt result in a goal). But you already pointed out that this is a known bug. 

      3:1 Victory (End of Regulation)

      Arcade Mode:

      Is much faster than the previous version. And it has better puck movement, which appears more fluent. But I witnesssed some uncontrolled speed bursts, when players flew across the screen. Players appear more unsorted on the ice, so defense isnt set in many situations. Instead they take the whole ice. 

      0:1 Loss (End of Regulation)

      Regular Mode

      All in all this felt very familiar. Like an improved version of the original game. It was very fluent and balanced, but it was too hard to score for me. I had some great shots, but wasnt able to knock one down. 

      0:2 Loss (End of Regulation)

       

      Cheers mate, I hope this helps :)

      • Thanks 1
      Link to comment
      Share on other sites

      @fastlane You rule! Thanks again for all the feedback, it really helps. 

      lol - I'm so sorry that your goalie doesn't like you. :)

      I agree with your assessment of the arcade mode, but after the first one, just about everyone asked for faster, so… it's faster. I know it can be crazy unrealistic sometimes.

      It sounds like Rookie mode works now! Great. Will just implement the final fixes, and put out one final version just to make sure there are no errors. But no major changes. No minor changes even. Just final fixes.

      Thanks again for you all your help!

       

       

      Edited by AdamCatalyst
      typo
      • Love 1
      Link to comment
      Share on other sites

      1 hour ago, AdamCatalyst said:

      @fastlane You rule! Thanks again for all the feedback, it really helps. 

      lol - I'm so sorry that your goalie doesn't like you. :)

      I agree with your assessment of the arcade mode, but after the first one, just about everyone asked for faster, so… it's faster. I know it can be crazy unrealistic sometimes.

      It sounds like Rookie mode works now! Great. Will just implement the final fixes, and put out one final version just to make sure there are no errors. But no major changes. No minor changes even. Just final fixes.

      Thanks again for you all your help!

       

       

      I cant wait! Thanks for this great and huge update package! 

      • Love 1
      Link to comment
      Share on other sites

      Join the conversation

      You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

      Guest
      Reply to this topic...

      ×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

        Only 75 emoji are allowed.

      ×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

      ×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

      ×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

      ×
      ×
      • Create New...