I've tried searching the post titles, and tweaked google to look back to 2005 - but nothing.
If we could track down the url, you could use the 'waybackmachine' to search archived pages of the site.
Team Name:Toronto Maple Leafs First Line LW: John Cullen #19 C: Alex Mogilny #89 RW: Robert Reichel #26 LD: Al MacInnis #2 RD: JJ Daignault #48 X: Guy Carbonneau #21 G: Bob Essensa #35 Second Line LW: Guy Carbonbeau #21 C:24 Robert Reichel #26 RW: Doug Weight #39 LD: Fred Olausson #4 RD: Alexei Kasatonov #7 X: Shayne Corson #9 G: Pat Jablonski (change to #1)