A couple of general responses.
- I notice that when folks have really strong opinions about how people not playing their games can be fixed, it is often a result of a combination of their own above-average enthusiasm and commitment to the leagues, and not really getting their head around the fact that this community numbers in the "dozens", not the "hundreds" or "thousands" or "etc.". We haven't really hit the magical tipping point where intellectually complicated schemes are going to work, despite the logic on paper. Because at the end of the day the person thinking up the plan usually doesn't factor in that 90% of the rest of the community isn't as fired up about video game leagues as he is.
- In MLB, teams that lose in extra innings get no points. In the NFL, teams that lose in sudden death overtime, after losing the coin flip and never even touching the ball on offense, get no points. In the NBA, teams that lose in quadruple overtime get no points. These leagues have managed to survive on the concept that two competitors battle until there is a winner and a loser, and that the loser of the game is treated the same no matter how much of a moral victory he may have earned along the way. I understand that there are folks out there who want "partial credit", but not everyone here needs that.